|
TomTom Navigator 5 for PalmOS
[ Home ] [ Mapopolis ] [ DeLorme ] [ TomTom ] [ Contact Me ]
| **
Updated Review ** |
| TomTom
has released two updates to TomTom Navigator 5 (v5.12 and
v5.201) since this review was first written. I also
changed Palm devices from a Tungsten|C to the new T|X.
Please see the review updates below for more information
regarding TomTom running on the T|X as well as new screenshots
of the bigger T|X screen. Updated sections are
(obviously) marked with "UPDATED!".
|
|
| What's
in the Box? |
Box? What
box? I purchased the software-only option from www.Semsons.com
($125 at the time of this writing) instead of buying one of
their combo packages that include a GPS receiver. Even
though the picture on both Semsons and TomTom's website shows
a box, the software does not come in any sort of retail
packaging. What you do get is the following:
- One Quick Start Guide
(which at first looks like a substantially thick pamphlet,
until you discover that it includes French, Spanish, and
English versions, 12 pages per language)
- One six-step, foldout Installation
sheet
- A microprint License
Agreement (I think there are real words on there, but
cannot see them)
- A product code card (looks
like a credit card)
- One Application and User
Manual CD in a paper sleeve
- Eight Maps CDs in
paper sleeves
- One marketing pamphlet
advertising the TomTom Plus service
Although everything was in good
order, the Instructions and Quick Start Guide
pretty much proved worthless, as the installation for this
product did not go well at all. I am not used to paying
$125 for retail software that does not come in a retail box --
not a big thing, but an eyebrow raiser for sure.
|
|
| UPDATED!
Installation |
| In a word:
HORRIBLE!
Putting in the Application
and User Manual CD was uneventful, and the installation
automatically started up as usual. The menus and prompts
were all fine with nothing complicated or confusing. I
selected to have the application installed on the internal
memory of my Palm, concluding that I would then install the
maps on my expansion card. Everything APPEARED to go
well. After successfully going through the application
install (but not yet Hotsyncing), I then installed voice and
map files. Finally, I Hotsync'ed...or at least attempted
to do so. I always Hotsync via Wi-Fi even when handling
larger files like maps, videos, etc. For some reason,
the Hotsync continually failed, with an error message that I
had lost my Wi-Fi connection. I have since and prior
installed other apps via a Wi-Fi Hotsync, and not encountered
this issue. So, I hook up the cradle to my computers USB
port and again attempted to Hotsync the installation.
This time it does work...took forever and a day...but at least
the Hotsync was successful. But wait -- where is the
TomTom Navigator app? All I saw was Contacts Navigator,
which did nothing but bring up a version of my address
book. I searched in all my categories, refreshed my
launcher, even used a file manager and could not find anything
that resembled Navigator.prc, TTN5.prc, etc. Using the
file manager, I eventually found what I assumed to be the app
-- Start.prc -- which I deduced only because it had the same
creator as CN.prc (Contacts Navigator), which is MniC (don't
ask, because I don't know). However, even though I found
Start.prc, it still wouldn't show up in my launcher (Launcher
X). Off to the internet I go for a Google search on the
problem. Sure enough, everyone running a third-party launcher
was having this same problem. The Navigator icon DOES
show up in the default Palm launcher. Each third-party
launcher has its own work-around for this issue, but most of
the workarounds are kludgey or not an effective solution every
time. The solution I had to use was to change the
creator information of Contacts Navigator from MniC to xxxx,
which then (for some bizarre reason) allowed the Start.prc app
to appear in my launcher under the name Navigator.
However, when I use Contacts Navigator to select an address
that I want to route to, Contacts Navigator reports an error,
stating that it cannot run the Navigator app.
So, close to two hours later I
have a working copy of Navigator on my Palm with one minor
caveat concerning the link between Contacts Navigator and
Navigator, right? Wrong. Every time I ran the
initial setup for Navigator, it couldn't find any voice files,
even though (again using the file manager) I could see the
voice files on my Palm. Back out to the internet to
Google the problem, but this time no luck! Back out to
the internet to search for 3rd-party TomTom forums, but since
TomTom Navigator 5 for Palm OS is such a new product, the only
information I could find seemed to be mostly about the
PocketPC European version. Finally, I found a small GPS
forum that referenced this problem. Apparently the voice
files had to be in the same folder as the Start.prc
file. Folder? This is a Palm device, not a
PocketPC -- we don't have folders. Well, apparently this
guy was only able to get it to work by installing EVERYTHING
to the SD expansion card.
...Sigh...
Okay, deleted TomTom completely
from my Palm and used my favorite backup application,
AdvancedBackup, to find any leftovers that the deletion left
behind. Reinstalled everything. However, this time
I only installed the applications and the voice files via
Hotsync, and I installed them to the SD expansion card instead
of internal memory. I then took advantage of the
advanced options for installing the maps, and had them copied
to a folder on my desktop PC instead. I then used a card
reader to copy them to the SD card. More weirdness
occurred though, because Contacts Navigator (CN.prc) was
installed to the \PALM\Launcher folder on my SD card, but for
some reason Navigator (Start.prc) was installed to the \PALM
folder. The voice files were installed to a newly
created \TomTom folder, and the maps I knew to manually
install to the appropriate map name folder (in my case,
\Southeast-Map). Again, the fiasco where Navigator (Start.prc)
does not show up in my launcher, but this time I get TWO icons
for Contacts Navigator (CN.prc) -- one regular icon and
showing that it was installed to the memory card.
I then decided that where
TomTom was apparently lacking common sense, I would insert my
own. I moved the Navigator app (Start.prc) to the
\PALM\Launcher folder, made sure that there was only one
instance of Contacts Navigator (CN.prc) and that it was
installed in \PALM\Launcher, verified that all the voice files
were only in the \TomTom folder on my SD card, and also looked
for other stray apps in my Palms internal memory. This
got me back to where I started -- I couldn't see the Navigator
app in my launcher. So I again changed the Contacts
Navigator owner information to xxxx, and decided to just live
with the communication break between Contacts Navigator and
Navigator. I then ran the initial startup for Navigator
and this time it found all the voice files and the maps
without a hitch.
I started the install at around
10:00pm and finally had a working Navigator install at about
3:30am. Definitely a record for me, especially
concerning Palm apps. I am a career network engineer,
and have installed wide area networks from the workstation all
the way up to the server and network hardware/wiring,
including multiple network operating systems, protocols,
etc. Basically, I'm not exactly computer stupid, and I
pity anyone buying this product who is less technical, because
this install process is flat-out wacky.
UPDATE!
TomTom finally responded to my technical support
requests. They informed me that I need to install the
voice files to the SD card instead of to internal memory
(where it defaults). They did not mention anything about
the 3rd-party launcher issue, but they did release the TomTom
Navigator 5.12 update, which corrects this problem similarly
to the way that I did by changing the creator information on
the Contacts Navigator application (CN.prc). Apparently,
they account for the creator name change in the
Navigator/Contacts Navigator programming though, because now
the communication between the two applications is
working. Both Navigator and Contacts Navigator can now
be installed in internal memory.
UPDATE!
TomTom has released two new versions since I first
posted this review. The v5.12 update corrected a lot of
problems with the installation, as did the v5.201
update. The installation is still a little quirky
though, and still installs two copies of CN and START -- one
in your Palm's memory and one on your memory card. I
simply deleted the duplicate that was installed on the memory
card.
The v5.201 update also brought
reports of new problems from other TomTom users, specifically
problems with DB Cache errors. I did not encounter these
errors on the Tungsten|C, but did encounter them from time to
time on the T|X, which has significantly less cache than the
T|C (for some reason -- not sure why Palm would do
this). A soft reset of the T|X would usually flush the
cache and allow TomTom to run, so at least there was an
obvious work-around to the problem. Honestly, I blame
Palm more than TomTom on this one, as it really does not make
much sense to put out a newer Palm product that has lesser
features/configuration.
|
|
| Initial
Impressions |
| In a word:
WOW!
The interface is very different
from Mapopolis and DeLorme. It reminds me more of a
built-in car navigation system, whereas the Mapopolis and
DeLorme seem more like handheld/Palm apps. You can do
almost everything with your finger instead of a stylus,
something that makes it much more realistic to use it in the
car while driving. The maps are
very nice, and after browsing around my home town map, they
appear to be very accurate and have the most recent data out
of the three apps. There are more features and unique
options in TomTom than even in DeLorme, which was in turn
heads and shoulders above Mapopolis. I
was and still am confused as to why the only access you have
to your Palm Contacts database is via the separate
application, Contacts Manager. There is no method
embedded into the main Navigator application that allows you
to access your Palm Contacts. Mapopolis offers this, and
even DeLorme offers a method of importing your Contacts
database permanently into the DeLorme Palm
application. |
|
| Screenshots |
| |

It's just not a real in-car GPS navigation system
unless it gives you the warning screen on startup! |

This is the default startup screen without a GPS and
not in 3D mode. Notice the colors are "greyed". |
| |
|

This is the default startup screen without a GPS and
in 3D mode. |

Startup screen not in 3D mode, but with the GPS
attached -- the colors are back. |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|

Not only is there embedded help, but also a full-blown
Guided Tour -- on the Palm! |

Here are the six different Guided Tours that are
available. |
| |
|

This is a screenshot from the Browse Map tour
|

This is a screenshot from the Route Planning tour
|
| |
|

Another screenshot from the Route Planning tour,
showing you the status bar information. |

This is the GPS Status screen that shows the usual
satellite locations, signal strength, and coordinates. |
| |
|

This is using the Browse Map function with the POIs
set to display. |

Same Browse Map function with the POIs turned off |
| |
|

The Itinerary function is a nice feature to use once
you have arrived at your destination. |

With the Itinerary function you can assign different
POIs
or specific addresses/locations to visit while in
town. |
| |
|

From the Itinerary list, you can be routed to the
various
locations, rearrange the list priority, show the item on
a
map, or mark it as "visited" like checking off
a
to-do list. |

This is the Navigate To screen, giving you various
destination options. |
| |
|

This is the second Navigate To screen, giving you more
destination options. |

If you tap on "Address" in the previous
Navigate To
menus, you have to complete the City field first.
The
three listed cities above are recent destinations I have
used. |
| |
|

You are then prompted for the road name. |

Prior to being prompted for house number, I received
this pop-up tip, offering to use the Crossing
option
rather than house number. Various tips like this
appear
from time to time when initially navigating through
the
application. |
| |
|

You now enter the street number. |

You are then offered a screen (not displayed here) to
select routing options, like Quickest, Fastest, Avoid
Highways, etc. The route is then calculated and an
overall routing screen similar to the one above will
be displayed. |
| |
|

If you tap the Route button in the previous overall
routing
screen, you are presented with the above options.
This
is where you can avoid construction, add a
"Via" or
simply allow the program to offer you an alternative
route. |

When you select Avoid Part of Route, you are then
offered a written display of the entire route where you
can click on the segment you want/need to avoid. |
| |
|

Once you have the route set, your are shown the routing
screen. This is the 2D mode. |

If you tap anywhere on the routing screen, you will be
offered the above options, which are different ways of
viewing the route. |
| |
|

This is the Browse as Text route option |

This is the Browse as Images route option |
| |
|

This is the Browse Map of Route routing option |

This is the first screen of the Show Route Demo option.
You set the speed of the demo here, and then it will
actually take you to a demo of what it would be like
to drive this route. If the demo speed is low
enough,
it will even provide voice prompts! |
| |
|

The following five screen shots are all the Preferences
options. There are plenty! |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
|
| |
|

The rest of the screen shots are individual Preferences
options shown with further detail. |
 |
| |
|

You get the choice of about eight or so color schemes.
You cannot modify colors individually, but the included
schemes provide you with a pretty good selection. |

Another color scheme. You can also download
additional
color schemes via TomTom Plus. |
| |
|

This is actually a night color scheme |

This is also a night color scheme |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
|
|
| UPDATED!
Screenshots on the Palm T|X |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
| |
|
 |
 |
|
| Note:
The display of the Palm T|X can be rotated for either
portrait (above) or landscape (below): |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
 |
| |
|
| UPDATED!
Road
Test |
| In a word: SUPERB!
The road test was very surprising because of the way the
TomTom handles scrolling and rotating the maps compared to
Mapopolis and DeLorme. Whereas the other two apps
provide jerking/quirky map scrolling/rotation, TomTom is very
smooth -- basically like a movie or a video game.
TomTom also does something that I've found unique among the
three navigation apps -- it seems to "snap to" the
nearest road. For example, if there's new construction
where they move an entire road section over 500 feet from its
previous location, even though your GPS coordinates would show
that you are off of the road in Mapopolis or DeLorme, TomTom
will initially and briefly show you as being offroad, but then
will move you over to the old road on the map. This may
have a drawback in denser areas with a lot of roads close
together. I could see the TomTom app getting confused on
which road to snap to. However, after driving long
stretches of new highway where I appear to be driving on the
side of the road in Mapopolis, this TomTom snap to feature is
a welcome one in my book.
The voice prompts were very
accurate and clear, and seemed to provide more information
than the the other two applications. The choice of
voices (accents, languages, etc.) is very nice. I also
liked the way the navigation/voice system seemed to take it
just that much further than the other two applications by a
"reassurance" type feature. TomTom would
actually reassure me that I was still on the right track by
stating, "Continue straight" or "Right turn
ahead," when I would come to a
major intersection on my route. Not a big thing, really,
but another nice touch by TomTom that makes it seem like more
of a professional system.
Everything was very accurate in my road testing, and the
user interface was much easier to navigate in TomTom versus
the other two when on the road. I simply cannot
emphasize enough that the new TomTom version could easily
replace a factory in-car navigation system.
UPDATED!
The road test with
TomTom Nav 5 on a Palm T|X was even better than on the T|C.
Depending on the mounting bracket you're using, you can easily
rotate the TomTom display in the TomTom config and then
physically rotate your Palm to be landscape. This makes
your Palm based GPS even more like the factory in-car
navigation systems. On a personal note, it was also nice
that my mount is black, the T|X is black, and even my Holux
GM210 is mostly black -- made for a very slick, nice looking
setup. As for display orientation, I like the taller
display (portrait), as when you are driving down the highway
at 70mph you probably will not care as much about what is on
either side of you as much as what is in front of you and
behind you. Voice prompts
were very clear on the T|X, as the T|X offers a very nice
speaker. I did not like that the T|X does not have a
charge light on it because it made it difficult to tell if the
charging cable was working properly.
|
|
| UPDATED!
Customer
Support |
| Well, here is where TomTom is going to take a
hit. Although a few people have reported great
communications from TomTom technical support, I have yet to
hear anything from my technical support case (regarding the
poor install and that the icons do not show up in most 3rd
party launchers). They also do not offer an on-site
forum like DeLorme does, and even 3rd party support via forums
does not seem to exist (at least at this time) for North
American version or even the Palm platform.
Note: Please see update
above. TomTom Support finally did respond to trouble
ticket, but there was a significant delay in the
response.
UPDATE!
Since my initial trouble ticket delay, I have
communicated numerous times with TomTom via their
website. All responses have been much faster than my
initial trouble ticket, and they were even very cooperative
during the dreaded 3x license switch that I did:
- Original T|C
- Palm T|X
- Second T|C
That put the license one reset
beyond what I could do by myself. TomTom support
actually telephoned *ME*, and gave me a new registration
number right over the phone. You cannot beat that kind
of support, and this significantly improves over my original
rating of their support.
|
|
| UPDATED!
Conclusion |
| TomTom Navigator 5 is THE application to
get. It's currently cheaper than Mapopolis and there is
no comparison when it comes to features between the two.
DeLorme gives TomTom a run for the money when it comes to
features, but the DeLorme user interface is a tad non-Palm
friendly (requires a lot of stylus work), and the on-Palm
routing simply cannot compare with TomTom's. I do not
regret the purchase of TomTom Navigator 5, even when that
horrible installation process is still so fresh on my mind.
I am sure the installation process will become easier if
TomTom ever corrects it, but even if they do not I am sure
that public forums will soon start posting solutions to the
installation woes.
THE GOOD:
- Map quality
- Nice new (for Palm version)
user interface
- 3-D display mode
- Extended routing features
such as Via's, alternate routes, detours, etc.
- Smooth scrolling/rotation
- $25 Cheaper than its closest
real competition
- UPDATE!
Support moves to "Good"!
THE BAD:
- UPDATE!
Installation (see update
above for improved installation) is still not the
greatest.
- Cannot route across map
regions (no coast-to-coast routing)
- Cannot use coordinates as a
destination in routing or search for a location.
- Contacts Manager - access to
Palm contacts should be embedded in main program
AND THE UGLY:
- UPDATE!
Installation used to be in the UGLY category. It has
gotten better, but it is still BAD.
|
|
| Comments? |
| If you have any
comments you would like to make regarding this review or in
regard to the applications themselves, please feel free to
leave a comment in the Comments
section of the weblog article.
|
|
|
|